GOP Leadership Fight After Midterms: Why Vance and Rubio Hold Back
Republicans are searching for a new direction after the Nov. 3 midterm elections handed Democrats control of both the House and the Senate, and the party’s two most-watched figures for 2028, Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, are keeping their own ambitions largely out of view. The GOP leadership after the midterms is taking shape in Congress, but the bigger question of who leads the party once President Donald Trump leaves office remains open. Meanwhile, the war with Iran is set to continue at least until the new Democratic majorities take power on Jan. 3, 2027.
GOP leadership after the midterms: a divided conference picks new leaders
House Republicans chose Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan as their leader for the next Congress on Nov. 10, defeating outgoing Majority Leader Steve Scalise of Louisiana 106-73 in a closed-door, secret-ballot election that stretched for hours, Roll Call reported. The contest opened after Speaker Mike Johnson announced the week before that he would not seek a leadership post once his party moved into the minority. Johnson did not endorse a candidate but said of Jordan afterward: “He’s going to do an excellent job.”
In the Senate, the frustration was more visible. Senate Republicans reelected John Thune of South Dakota as their leader on the same day, but only after a push by Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson to postpone the vote. The conference voted to proceed, and Johnson left the room as voting began, according to the Associated Press. Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley backed the delay, saying, “If you don’t think after losing seven seats minimum that we need to change course, I don’t know what planet you’re on.” Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul offered a blunter diagnosis: “The cost of living defeated us.”
Why JD Vance and Marco Rubio are holding back
Trump has repeatedly named Vance and Rubio as possible successors, but neither has moved to claim the party after its losses. Their caution follows a rare public split over the war.
Shortly after the election, Vance wrote on X: “The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.” Rubio took the opposite line days later, defending the decision to fight Iran: “Presidents are elected to take on the hard things, sometimes difficult things, but necessary things.” Asked about the midterms, Rubio said he does not comment on domestic politics, Fox News reported.
Since then, Vance has said he is focused on his current job, has played down talk of a 2028 campaign and has said neither he nor Rubio is “entitled” to the presidency, the Deseret News reported. He has called Rubio his “best friend” in the administration. Both serve a president with two years left, and open positioning now would mean breaking with Trump on the war or owning a policy most voters rejected.
Will the Iran war continue until Democrats take over in January?
For now, yes. The war began in late February, and on Nov. 19 the Senate rejected a war powers resolution 48-51 in the first vote on the conflict since the midterms, CBS News reported. Republican Sens. Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski and Rand Paul voted yes; Democrat John Fetterman voted no.
The next pressure point is money. Congress must pass a funding bill by Dec. 11 to avoid a shutdown, and Democrats are divided over whether to try to restrict war spending in that bill or wait until they hold the gavels. Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia said, “When we have the gavels, we are contemplating other things.” Rep. Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, has filed a new war powers resolution and hopes to force a House vote before the lame-duck session ends. The war had cost at least $48.3 billion as of Nov. 13, according to testimony cited by Roll Call.
Even in January, Democrats’ options will be limited. With 56 Senate seats and about 257 House seats as counting finishes, they will fall well short of the two-thirds majorities needed to override a veto, leaving funding restrictions as their main tool.
How the economy, immigration and the Iran war shaped voter decisions
The national Voter Poll conducted by SSRS for major news networks pointed to three overlapping forces, according to a summary by the American Enterprise Institute:
- Economy: 39% named it their most important issue. Some 62% said higher prices were mainly due to Trump’s policies, 65% said tariffs hurt the national economy, and 44% said their family finances were worse than two years ago.
- Immigration: 14% named it their top issue, and 57% said the administration’s enforcement has gone too far. Still, voters were nearly split on which party they trust on the issue, 44% Republican to 41% Democratic.
- Iran war: 63% said entering the war was the wrong decision, and 74% called it a crucial or major factor in their vote, even though only 4% named foreign policy as their top issue.
The issues reinforced each other. In a post-election survey by the conservative group American Compass, about 85% of voters said the war had raised their own costs. Trump himself said after the election that voters “didn’t like the war” and that the immigration crackdown “helped and hurt” his party. For Republicans choosing leaders now, the message from voters centered on prices, with the war seen as a main driver of them.
Featured image: Noclip / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain).


