WorldEurope

COP31 Fossil Fuels Row Pushes Talks Into Overtime as EU Weighs Deal

The COP31 fossil fuels dispute has pushed the UN climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye, past its scheduled Friday, 20 November close, with negotiators from nearly 200 countries still split over whether the final deal should mention coal, oil and gas at all. For Europe, the outcome matters directly: the European Union arrived with a mandate to push for a faster clean energy shift, and several European governments are now openly lobbying to restore language that a slimmed-down draft removed on Thursday.

What the new COP31 draft dropped

The COP31 presidency, led by Turkish environment minister Murat Kurum with Australia’s climate and energy minister Chris Bowen chairing the negotiations, released a revised political text, the so-called cover decision, on the afternoon of 19 November. According to UN News and Irish broadcaster RTÉ, the nine-page document is roughly half the length of the first 18-page draft issued on 16 November, and it no longer contains any explicit reference to moving away from fossil fuels.

The main changes reported by those outlets and by Reuters include:

  • Removal of both options on fossil fuels that appeared in the earlier draft: accelerating the 2023 commitment to “transition away” from coal, oil and gas, and a stronger “phase out” formula.
  • Removal of a proposed target of at least $120 billion a year in adaptation finance for developing countries by 2035; the existing pledge to triple adaptation finance stays, with the baseline and delivery path left for further talks.
  • Retention of Türkiye’s “35 by 35” goal to raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035, though with softer wording.
  • An acknowledgement that global warming is projected to exceed 1.5°C, with a call to keep any overshoot as small and short as possible.

Kurum presented the text as the “Antalya Declaration”. Bowen, quoted by RTÉ, called it the best basis for agreement in the time left and said COP31 would be the first summit to recognise that the 1.5°C ambition of the Paris Agreement will not be met. The draft itself is published on the UN Climate Change (UNFCCC) website.

Why talks ran into overtime

Reuters reported on Friday that the deletion followed objections from Saudi Arabia and other major oil and gas producers, while Saudi Arabia and Venezuela argued in formal speeches for a continued role for fossil fuels. Climate-vulnerable countries pushed back hard. Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, told Reuters: “It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover document that does not even mention fossil fuels.” Vanuatu’s climate minister, Ralph Regenvanu, said: “We can see where it’s going, and it’s not going to be a high-ambition text.”

A further point of contention is the draft’s encouragement of carbon removal technologies, which several delegations described as costly and unproven at scale. The United States is absent from the process for a second year. A new draft was expected later on Friday, and recent climate summits have frequently run more than 24 hours beyond schedule.

What COP31 means for Europe

The EU’s reaction is likely to be pivotal. Ireland, which holds the rotating presidency of the Council of the EU, is coordinating member states in Antalya through its environment minister, Darragh O’Brien. He told RTÉ on Thursday that ministers had begun examining the text but had not reached conclusions: “We did not seek any opinions on it at this stage.” EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra said the bloc would judge the draft on three tests: whether it responds adequately to the risk of exceeding 1.5°C, whether it implements existing agreements, and whether it fits the mandate EU negotiators received from member states.

Several European governments are not waiting. According to Euronews, eight European and developing countries, including France, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway and Switzerland, signed an open letter on 20 November asking that the transition away from oil, gas and coal be “fully reflected” in the final decision. At home, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Finland have already published national fossil fuel transition roadmaps, and Denmark, Portugal, Luxembourg and Spain announced their own plans on 17 November.

For European households and businesses, a weak global signal would not change binding EU climate law, but it would affect the international backdrop for Europe’s energy policy, from the competitiveness of its clean-tech industry to the pace at which large emitters elsewhere cut emissions.

What happens next

Decisions at UN climate talks require consensus, so any single bloc can stall a deal. Watch for three things in the coming hours: whether a revised text restores fossil fuel wording, whether the EU formally backs or rejects the package, and whether adaptation finance figures return. Unresolved issues, notably the adaptation finance baseline, are expected to roll into next year’s negotiations, with COP32 due in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in 2027.

Featured image: Erik Karits / Unsplash (Unsplash License).


Javier Zelaya

Javier Zelaya is the Chief News Editor of MB Daily News, leading the publication’s English- and Spanish-language coverage of U.S. real estate, mortgage markets, and business, as well as economic and business developments across Central America and Latin America.

Latest News

Stay informed with our latest stories.